4th June 2021
On 5th May 2021, the Professional Standards Authority invited Harmed Patients Alliance and other Patient Organisations to a roundtable discussion on the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) consultation Regulating healthcare professionals, protecting the public with proposals to modernise the legislation of the health professional regulators.
The consultation is open until 12:15am on 16th June 2021 and we recommend all our readers respond.
Discussions focused around the following areas of concern.
Oversight of accepted outcomes
The proposed accepted outcomes process would mean that even the most serious of cases could be concluded without any need for a panel hearing provided the registrant agrees with the decision. Since only decisions of panels can be reviewed by the Professonal Standards Authority this could mean that the outcome of these cases could not be challenged by the PSA through its section 29 powers. patients and families would not be able to have an independent review of decisions taken under the accepted outcomes route that would previously have gone to panel. Participants agreed there is a need for a safety net to allow for challenge of accepted outcomes.
Further to this, patient organisations present felt that there should be a mechanism for patients/families to ask for independent review of decisions made earlier on in the process, so decisions not to investigate at all, or decisions not to take any action/ proceed to panel after investigation. The current lack of a mechanism to have these decisions independently reviewed is not satisfactory for patients and families.
In the proposed new system, any individual could request the registrar to review a decision made through the accepted outcomes process. This could give patients and families more of a role, however, the registrar would only have the power to review the decision in tightly specified circumstances and in fact could choose not to even do so. In addition, those requesting the review wouldn’t have the same level of information available to them as the Professional Standards Authority currently does through its Section 29 powers and the regulator would be in the position of deciding whether to review or reviewing its own decisions (concentration of powers).
There was a view that the registrar should not simply have the power to review decisions that are challenged, both in terms of accepted outcomes and decisions not to investigate / put a case to a panel , but a duty to do so. Alternatively, it was proposed that the Authority could have an explicit power to challenge a registrar decision not to take forward a review on request at any stage of the process.
The concerns about oversight of accepted outcomes relate to the Government’s proposals on pages 79 to 81, and to questions 61, 62, and 63 of the consultation document.
Removal of 5 year rule
All attendees stated there was huge support for the removal of the 5-year rule, which would allow regulators greater discretion when deciding wether or not to investigate concerns dating back further than this. There was discussion that this proposal is not a given, and it will be important that as many members of the public and organisations respond in support of this proposal as possible.
Independent advice for patients
Patient organisations were disappointed that the need for quality support and advice for the public and patients to navigate the health professional regulatory system is not addressed by the consultation at all.
Grounds for action
The Government has proposed that the grounds on which regulators can take action will be reduced to two across all regulators, no longer including one relating to health. The concern here is that it may make it more difficult for regulators to manage concerns proactively about the impact of a registrant’s health on his/her fitness to practise. Instead, regulators may need to wait for the harm to happen before being able to take action. The rationale for this proposal is unclear to us.
This proposal is covered by question 44 within the consultation document.
Oversight of Rule Making
Under the new proposals, regulators will be able to make changes to their fitness to practise rules without parliamentary or Privy Council scrutiny; they will, however, be required to consult on significant changes to rules and standards. This has the potential to be beneficial both in terms of efficiency and patient safety since regulators will be able to adapt their procedures more quickly. However, there is a lack of clarity on which rules and standards the regulators will be required to consult on, as well as concerns over ensuring that the perspective of patients, the public and services users is appropriately sought and understood.
There are no proposals for any independent oversight of the rule making process to ensure rules which protect the public and avoid unjustifiable inconsistencies. The Law Commissions previously proposed a role for the Authority to oversee regulator rulemaking.
There is no specific question on this issue in the consultation document.
Harmed Patients Alliance will be submitting our response to the consultation shortly, informed by this roundtable discussion and our own review of the proposals, and will make this available on our website when it is submitted.
Views of other organisations that may interest you can be found here;
Professional Standards Agency
https://www.professionalstandards.org.uk/what-we-do/reforming-regulation-ensuring-public-protection
Patients Association
https://www.professionalstandards.org.uk/news-and-blog/blog/detail/blog/2021/05/26/regulatory-reform-a-perspective-from-the-patients-association
AvMA
https://www.avma.org.uk/policy-campaigns/patient-safety/health-professional-regulation/